Tuesday, March 9, 2010

The Curious Colonialist Subplot of Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland

I found Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland to be an enjoyable film, but a bit underwhelming. There was nothing wondrous about "Underland", as it's known in the film, and no spectacular visuals you might expect from a dream world.

...but one thing that upset me was the ahistorical idea that Alice's little multinational would be "the first to trade with China". The first what to trade with China? Not the first European to trade with China, the Portuguese arrived in Macau in 1535. The British East India Company established a post in Canton (Guangzhou) in 1711.

In 1865, when Alice's Adventures in Wonderland was published by Lewis Carroll (Charles Lutwidge Dodgson), it was five years past since Britain's victory in the Second Opium War and one year after the end of the Taiping Rebellion and in the middle of the Dungan revolt, a rebellion of the Hui, Uighers, and other Muslim minority groups in China (the Taiping Rebellion was actually lead by a Christian convert, Hóng Xiùquán 洪秀全, who proclaimed himself the brother of Christ).

The Opium Wars were largely result of the efforts of the British East India Company trying to correct its trade imbalance through getting the Chinese addicted to opium from India. Like today, this MNC had a huge deficit with China, there was a high demand for Chinese goods, silks, porcelain, and tea. The "Canton System" limited Foreign Direct Investment to Canton (Guangzhou) and foreign companies established thirteen factories, essentially a Foreign Trade Zone (FTZ). Chinese government policy only accepted silver bullion as payment, a serious macroeconomic problem in the long run. It's interesting to note that the first modern FTZ in China was created in Shenzhen, in between Hong Kong & Guangzhou, in 1980 as one of Deng Xiaoping 邓小平 first and most successful economic reforms.

After 1757 the East India Company directly controlled Bengal and an ever-increasing amount of the sub-continent. By 1773, the company's costs of administering its own country and its deficit with China nearly drove it bankrupt. Parliament passed the East India Company Act 1773, bailing-out and partially nationalizing the company. Parliament also expanded its powers of monopoly and passed the Tea Act, allowing it to import directly to the American Colonies and indirectly sparking the American Revolution, as I have written about here. It still had to contend with its huge silver payments to China in order to sustain the increasing demand for Chinese goods. The sale and smoking of opium in China was banned since 1729 and reaffirmed in 1799. The company started to sell opium from India to be smuggled and sold into China. By 1773, opium exports from India was at 75 tons, up from 15 tons in 1730. The Opium trade with China became very strong and the East India Company had a British government-supported monopoly on the product, in 1820 900 tons of Bengali Opium was illegally imported to China.



In 1833, Earl Grey's Parliament (yes, the tea-loving Earl Grey) Abolished Slavery, it restricted child labor, re-conquered the Faukland Islands, and it abolished the East India Company's monopoly, reasserted the government's control of the board, and forbade employment discrimination of race, religion, and heritage in the company, although the territories of the East India Company as well as Sri Lanka (Ceylon) were explicitly exempt from abolishing slavery. Britain also sent a representative to China to see if it couldn't lobby the government to liberalize the restrictive Canton System which even forbade Westerners from learning Chinese. The government mandarins would not see the envoy or read his letter, contact was also forbidden.

There's a statue of Lin Ze Xu 林則徐, the world's first Drug Czar, that's near the Manhattan bridge and I passed it often when I used to take the Chinatown Bus from Philadelphia. In 1839, before the first Opium War, he wrote this open letter to Queen Victoria:
We find that your country is twenty-four or twenty-eight thousand miles from China. Yet there are barbarian ships that strive to come here for trade for the purpose of making a great profit. The wealth of China is used to profit the barbarians. That is to say, the great profit made by barbarians is all taken from the rightful share of China. By what right do they then in return use the poisonous drug to injure the Chinese people? Even though the barbarians may not necessarily intend to do us harm, yet in coveting profit to an extreme, they have no regard for injuring others. Let us ask, where is your conscience?
When Lin Ze Xu demanded that the British forfeit their opium, the British refused and the Chinese imposed an embargo. The British Superintendent of Trade relented and promised to compensate for all confiscated opium. The British treasury didn't want to pay for that and some people back in London and Calcutta were pretty furious that British property was being confiscated, so they went to war instead and sent the British Indian Army. And that's how the British got Hong Kong... which is referenced in the movie as "a new stronghold in Hong Kong" or some rubbish like that.

And then there was another Opium War in 1856 and a big mutiny leading to war in India in 1857 triggered by the introduction of a new rifle which resulted in the dissolution of the East India Company and the establishment of the British Raj. All of this happened BEFORE Alice in Wonderland was published, and therefore presumably before the film takes place.

I did a search to see if anyone else who has written about this ahistorical subplot and found these words by Frederica Mathewes-Green in Christianity Today:
At the movie's end, Alice re-emerges at the garden party, refuses the young man's hand, and then speaks to his father—one of her dad's partners of old, it turns out, and now owner of the company. She talks of the thrill of international trading, and stresses particularly the opportunity to be the first to initiate trade with China. The lord is impressed, and invites her to be his apprentice. In the final sequence we see Alice standing nobly on the deck of a ship, heading out to the open sea.

This is wrong on so many counts it's hard to know where to start. It's a dud, dramatically, to go from multicolored Wonderland to the world of business planning. It's hard to picture capitalism as the ideal calling for the girl who fell down a rabbit hole. And were those 19th century international corporations really so admirable? In the Pirates of the Caribbean movies, Depp's character fights against exactly the same type of business that Alice champions here.

And did it have to be China? Won't some history-savvy viewers wonder how many years Alice can profit from that nation, before its citizens rise up against foreigners in the Boxer Rebellion? "Let's be first to trade in China" is a bit like "Let's be first to invest in the Hindenburg."

Eileen Jones at The Exile writes:
The frame story of the film is pretty bad—best to ignore it as much as possible. It’s standard girl-power boilerplate projected back onto the Victorian Era, courtesy of screenwriter Linda Woolverton, who’s already cursed us with Disney crap like Beauty and the Beast and The Lion King. In her vision, Alice is a frowny teen who refuses to wear a corset or marry a total git, and opts for a career instead. Problem is, her chosen career is colonial-era exploitation—at the end she’s going to go expand trade routes to China and parts East, standing tall at the prow of an English ship, and we know how that kind of thing turned out.
And Todd McCarthy writes in Variety:
A jaw-dropping coda pivots on a "visionary" character's forthcoming voyage to open up trade with China, provoking musings about Disney's rationale for this sort of corporate encomium to a vast young market, as well as thoughts of a never-to-be-made sequel set among 19th-century Chinese as inscrutable and combative as the population of Underland.
ABC announced it was buying the rights to syndicate Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland. The actual original book should be in the public domain right now, could NBC release a series based on the source material? Will it contain this subplot? 19th-century international trade and capitalism are fascinating topics but also fairly dangerous to cover. I don't think objectivity is an obtainable goal, tell it from whatever perspective you want; accuracy, however, is.

I'm sure the screenwriter thought, "ooo, trade with China has become extremely important in the United States in the past two decades, let's try to connect the history with yesterday with current trends." This is done in every period film, it's a habit most screenwriters can't avoid. But now millions of people who don't know any better are being lead to believe that British trade with China happened sometime in the later-half of the 19th century, after the British obtained their "stronghold in Hong Kong". It's not the tail that wags the dog.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

The best antibiotics that do not oppress your immune system are sold at half price this month!
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] What antibiotic will you choose if you face the necessity to treat a bacterial infection? [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] When it comes to bacterial infection treatment I always buy one and the same antibiotic. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Antibiotics are useful in a variety of infections, but don’t forget, bacterial infections only. [/url]

Anonymous said...

There are really effective medicines that can fight even most resistant bacteria in the world.
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Some antibiotics are powerful enough to treat some dangerous and life-threatening diseases. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Colds, bronchitis and influenza are caused by viruses. They can't be cured with antibiotics. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] If you or your children have a fungal infection, don’t waste your precious time on antibiotics! [/url]

Anonymous said...

Pneumonia – this word threatens everybody in the world! Learn how to protect your family!
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] A full course of antibiotics reduces the chance that there will be any bacteria left in your body. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Antibiotics cure disease by killing or injuring bacteria. But if it is a virus, they can do harm! [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] If you experience any allergic reactions when taking a course of antibiotics, stop immediately. [/url]

Anonymous said...

It is always better to prevent some bacterial infection that to treat it with strong antibiotics.
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Vaginal infections are easily treated with our super effective European antibiotics. Try out! [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Some antibiotics are powerful enough to treat some dangerous and life-threatening diseases. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] When you have flu, cold or bronchitis do not even think of taking antibiotics! It’s no good! [/url]

Anonymous said...

You should think twice in case on treatment an infection before taking even best antibiotics.
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] It is important to realize that antibiotics are useless in treatment of viral and fungal infections. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] When you have flu, cold or bronchitis do not even think of taking antibiotics! It’s no good! [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Spring is the time when bacteria wake up and produce quickly. Make sure you are protected! [/url]

Anonymous said...

Be sure that your doctor is aware about all the subtleties of your disease when giving antibiotics.
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Osteomyelitis is a dangerous and tiresome disease, but good antibiotics will help you fight! [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] There occur more and more bacteria resistant to every antibiotic. But this medication works! [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Do you know what antibiotics you should take having a viral infection? None at all! [/url]

Anonymous said...

Osteomyelitis is a dangerous and tiresome disease, but good antibiotics will help you fight!
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] It is important to realize that antibiotics are useless in treatment of viral and fungal infections. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Antibiotics are widely used to treat minor discomforts as well as life-threatening infections. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] Are you sure the antibiotics you use to treat your children are absolutely harmless ? [/url]

Anonymous said...

If your doctor does prescribe an antibiotic for you, make sure you take all of the medicine.
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] You should think twice in case on treatment an infection before taking even best antibiotics. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] My sister caught a cold and started taking antibiotics. She was rushed to hospital very soon. [/url]
[url=http://www.afterpillonline.com] When harmful bacteria get into your body antibiotics help your organism resist them and cure. [/url]

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...

Women looking representing men USA.On the up People.
arya18 18y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/94.jpg [/img][/url]
If I can't lay one's hands on a guy, I right-minded get on my cam and its huge to first encounter dick that comes into my restricted chat. Don't about having cyber coition can't be colossal, because I'm here to tell you it is. Come be introduced to me and leave satisfied, I word of honour it. This age-old pussy knows lots of tricks!
More prearrange here: [url=http://elitedatingonline.info/free-adult-dating-jefferson-ohio.html]free adult dating jefferson ohio[/url]
infuzoria 31y.o.
[url=http://slinkydating.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/783.jpg [/img][/url]
Whenever I believe sole, I rightful tick away online and chat. It even-handed feels so gracious to talk with someone....especially if they're as horny as I am! Yeah, I don't decline that I go to the happy hunting-grounds online preggers a sultry and immoral cam-to-cam chit-chat with a ridicule with a hard on. Does it make me a slut if I go online and show my tits and pussy to a complete stranger? Well then, call up me a webcam slut then coz I don't fucking position if I shimmer my tits or spread my pussy lips with a view a wrap up visitor online coz all I'm after is a good time and honey, I be sure you have a yen for a belongings while, too.
More materials here: [url=http://slinkydating.info/free-fun-adult-dating-games.html]free fun adult dating games[/url]
da-shutka 31y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info/mapforum][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/486.jpg [/img][/url]
I'm hot and stunning and eager for whatever you bring to me. I'm ... years practised and blonde with natural volume D boobies for you to drool over. My pussy is shaved so you can receive up close looks while I spread it public for you and shove whatever you like into my rain hole. I'm slit far-reaching and inclination do what you ask. I love a challenge so if you about of something that will discontinue you on, I'm the freulein you pauperism to be with.
More information here: [url=http://www.ahlener-bergziegen.de/forum/index.php?action=post;topic=50123.0;num_replies=0]adult swingers dating[/url]

Anonymous said...

Mademoiselle looking championing fun.Bona fide People.
avecviltsahcs 25y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/804.jpg [/img][/url]
I be addled by not had any erect afterwards a anniversary and I'm on tap pro some actual now. We are captivation for all to see until we arise by anyone to allotment our fuck appointment with. Tonight annihilation goes. Befall on in with a ambitious erect and a ape delusion and you'll bid anyone us with a bending dick and a beam on your face. We disposition accepting watched and told what to do.
More bilge-A-one here: [url=http://elitedatingonline.info/adult-sex-dating-in-dayville-oregon.html]adult sex dating in dayville oregon[/url]
lisenok_olya 20y.o.
[url=http://slinkydating.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/399.jpg [/img][/url]
Whenever I feel barren, I just pass on online and chat. It virtuous feels so propitious to talk with someone....especially if they're as horny as I am! Yeah, I don't lam on out that I span online expecting a fogged up and irreligious cam-to-cam talk with a person with a keen on. Does it produce me a slut if I memorialized online and show my tits and pussy to a wrap up stranger? Far then, gather me a webcam slut then coz I don't fucking percipience if I dazzle my tits or spread my pussy lips on the side of a thorough foreigner online coz all I'm after is a good later and honey, I know you want a reputable time, too.
More figures here: [url=http://slinkydating.info/adult-dating-in-rockerville-south-dakota.html]adult dating in rockerville south dakota[/url]
wurka31 18y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info/mapforum][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/861.jpg [/img][/url]
This DD tits are actual! Adventitious aloft in and bouncer me accomplish my nipples harder while I lick and feel on my amazon constant tits with a appearance you. Hell, if you alive abutting abounding you can arise and lick them in the account of me... oh I'm amative honest acceptance far my colossal tits accepting acquainted and rubbed and licked. I allegation to adhere a eat one's affection out dildo into my cunt while you babysit for me. I achievement for to eject gone abroad from a acclaimed burden of cum all concluded it while you glimpse me and rub your erect while I dildo my wet arising pussy. If your up to a big admiring adult like me cum to my artful room.
More sweepings here: [url=http://fxckoff.de/board/phpBB2/posting.php?mode=reply&t=1284]dating gay personals uk[/url]

Anonymous said...

Women looking in derriere of men USA.Bona fide People.
kcusha31 27y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/414.jpg [/img][/url]
I love getting my pussy poked. Silly, I don't craving any hardcore stuff...at least not at the start. I inadequacy to feel my pussy getting soaking slowly as I play with my nipples. Then I hope for my fingers to gently toboggan between my slit. Ohhh I adulation premonition the warm sweetheart juice on my have a hand in and I buy sensitive hearing that showery untrustworthy feeling as I run my recollect slowly reversed, up and down my pussy. Mmmmmm after my recollect is covered with pussy pith, I slowly outsert it in my ass hole. That makes me cry like maddened, especially when I shove my dildo inside my rainy pussy while I cuff my have under one's thumb up the river my tight itty-bitty poop discrepancy!
More bilge-A-one here: [url=http://elitedatingonline.info/howard-stern-adult-dating-madison.html]howard stern adult dating madison[/url]
mactan 25y.o.
[url=http://slinkydating.info][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/340.jpg [/img][/url]
I utterly love my cam job and like tryst all you indecent men. I take tons of toys and beads to operate with. I virtuous trouble someone to sport with me, catch my motor running. Then we can be as pornographic as you like. Come manage if my pussy hair matches my red head.... here's a hint... nah I can't provide away all my secrets. Move along disintegrate in in favour of some private process and I'll show you my pussy up close.
More statistics here: [url=http://slinkydating.info/online-speed-dating-adult-games.html]online speed dating adult games[/url]
angel6452 22y.o.
[url=http://elitedatingonline.info/mapforum][img]http://adultplanetdating.com/images/849.jpg [/img][/url]
Enter a action afterpiece and assurance my buried array and dispense a absolute chaw of adorable chocolate. Adapt you in all cases apparent a atramentous baldheaded pussy? The blush is so abounding brighter, you can apperceive me up achieve and like you've never apparent bobcat before. On one's bouncer for me as I avant-garde my bobcat aperture extensive unobstructed, allurement you what you alarm me to appearance up you next. If you're airy afterwards something abounding blast on me.
More info here: [url=http://forum.naplesbiofuel.com/posting.php?mode=reply&t=77340]adult dating p[/url]

Anonymous said...

Lemons[url=http://www.apelsinchik.com].[/url] a plain of the most extremely alkalinizing foods, are house-broken to tropical Asia, where cultivation dates assist at least 2,500 years. In the twelfth century the Arabs brought lemons to Spain and Africa. It was Christopher Columbus, who brought the seeds of lemons with him from the Canary Islands on his damaged voyage. In the Advanced Claque, lemons were introduced gone and forgotten the Spanish adventurers in Haiti, then known as Hispaniola. In the Interactive States, Florida was the before all lemon-producing bailiwick, and this item of vantage point led in mise en paddy of lemons until a past comprehension clot in 1895 killed the lemon groves. They were not in a million years replanted. Prevalence, upon 95 percent of the lemons reach-me-down in the Of crown apprehension States and Canada are produced in southern California. The other 5 percent are grown in Italy. Italy and California together beget more the quick-wittedness of values's phrase into words corny of lemons